Baked by Melissa’s Founder Steps Down as CEO, and She’s Thrilled
Melissa Ben-Ishay moves to president to focus on product and brand as CFO Sanjay Khetan takes over. The company is also open to a sale for the first time.
Georgia Articles NewsroomSourced from 2 reports
Melissa Ben-Ishay built Baked by Melissa from a batch of cupcakes baked the night she was fired. In March 2026, she happily handed over the CEO title.
Ben-Ishay is stepping down as chief executive and returning to the title of president, the role she held before the board named her CEO in late 2019. The company’s chief financial officer, Sanjay Khetan, has taken over as CEO.
“No longer needed in that seat”
Ben-Ishay told Fortune she had hired Khetan with the goal of eventually replacing herself, and said she was thrilled she was no longer needed as CEO. Under the new structure, Khetan oversees operations and finance while Ben-Ishay leads brand and creative work.
The company is also open to being acquired for the first time. Ben-Ishay said Baked by Melissa regularly receives offers and is interested in exploring them.
Bite-size success
Ben-Ishay founded the company in 2008 at age 24 with her brother, Brian Bushell, who served as its first CEO until 2016. Over 18 years, Baked by Melissa says it has sold more than 500 million bite-size cupcakes through nine retail locations and nationwide shipping, while raising only about $6 million in outside funding.
Ben-Ishay has also become a social media star, with nearly 3 million TikTok followers. Her green goddess salad video alone has more than 27 million views.
For a founder whose business began with a firing, handing off the corner office looks more like a promotion of her own choosing.
Reporting we relied on
Something off? Tell the newsroom at newsroom@georgiaarticles.com and we'll look into it.


